← Case studies
Case study · Privacy

User-Collected Data: An Exercise in Information Privacy Expertise

Showed a user-installed app is not a recording device. The class action was dismissed.

The challenge

Class Action suit filed for alleged surreptitious recording of numerous public transportation passengers by public transportation client.

The client needed expertise for the following:

To opine on the difference between a device and an application.

To analyze and opine on the consensual nature of the installation of apps.

To draw comparisons and distinctions between the type of information captured through consent vs anonymous means.

Our approach

Our iDS experts drew upon their knowledge of law enforcement, investigative experience and deep technical backgrounds to describe the difference between hardware and software, as well as devices and applications.

The iDS Forensic and Investigative Team performed analysis and reported on the following:

That a specific app had to be user initiated for installation.

That a user had to “accept” the installation of the app, along with the acknowledgement that it was capturing certain non-

user identifiable information.

To describe to the court the differences between hardware defined surreptitious recording devices and user installed apps

that capture what most other apps also capture.

To describe to the court the difference between software key loggers that can capture every keystroke versus user installed

apps that do not identify individual people.

The result

Our team was able to show the court that a user installed app is not the same as a surreptitious recording device. The class action lawsuit was dismissed.


Client, matter, and party details are withheld to protect confidentiality.

More case studies
← All case studies
What is at stake

The earlier you understand the evidence, the better the decisions that follow.

The evidence is abundant. But volume is not access. Access is not understanding. And understanding is not an expert opinion.

Increasingly, evidence is buried across devices, applications, databases, cloud systems, transactions, and other complex sources. It must be found, preserved, made accessible, understood, and interpreted in the context of the matter. And when expert testimony is required, that understanding must support an independent, defensible opinion.

When important evidence surfaces late, assumptions may already have become strategy. When it is identified, tested, and understood early, your team can build its strategy around what can actually be shown. This isn’t just for trial. It is also for TROs, letters rogatory, discovery requests, subpoenas, depositions, summary judgment, mediation, and arbitration.

You bring the legal expertise. We bring the evidence expertise.

iDS combines technical, analytical, and subject-matter expertise to help you move from evidence to understanding, and, when necessary, from understanding to opinion and testimony.

You know the law. We help you know the evidence.

Bring us your question

Tell us what you need to establish. We will tell you what the evidence shows, what it does not, and what it means for your case.

Contact iDS

Not ready for that yet

Read how we approached matters that started as unanswerable questions. No client details, no case statistics.

See the Can You…? questions →
iDiscovery Solutions

Truth Through Data

Where expertise leads, defensible outcomes follow.

X f in ▶
Firm
About Us Capabilities Our Experts Speakers Can You…? Join Our Team
Thinking
AI & Evidence Insights Case Studies Publications iDocuMate
Offices
Washington, DC
3000 K Street NW, Suite 425
Washington, DC 20007
Costa Mesa, CA
535 Anton Blvd., Suite 860
Costa Mesa, CA 92626
Alpharetta, GA
11720 Amber Park Drive, Suite 160
Alpharetta, GA 30009
Contact
info@idsinc.com US: +1.800.813.4832 Bring us your question

Copyright © 2026 iDiscovery Solutions, Inc. All Rights Reserved  |  Privacy Policy  |  Cookie settings